i RE-EXAMINING GENDER, GENDER ROLES AND IDENTITY IN NIGERIA: THE FATTENING ROOM TRADITION OF THE EFIK (Report of Fieldwork) Akin-Otiko, Akinmayowa Eshiet, Idongesit Olokodana-James, Oluwatoyin Edisua, Merab Yta ii Copyright© 2022 Akin-Otiko, Akinmayowa Akinmayowa; Eshiet, Idongesit; Olokodana-James, Oluwatoyin; and Edisua, Merab Yta All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the author. ISBN: 978-978-998-458-9 Published By Lagos-African Cluster Centre, University of Lagos, Nigeria Printed By University of Lagos Press and Bookshop Ltd Works and Physical Planning Complex Unilag P.O. Box 132, University of Lagos, Akoka, Yaba - Lagos, Nigeria. e-mail: unilagpress@yahoo.com, unilagpress@gmail.com website: www.unilagpress.com Tel: 07039435625 iii RESEARCH TEAM Lagos-ACC Principal Investigators Akinmayowa Akin-Otiko, Ph.D., is a researcher at the Institute of African and Diaspora Studies (IADS), University of Lagos and has a special interest in the Religions, Cultures and Traditional Medicine of Africa. He has a BA and MA in Philosophy, from the University of Ibadan in 1996 and 2006, respectively. In 2013, he defended his Ph.D. in African Religion and Belief System, from the Institute of African Studies, University of Ibadan. Over the years, he has engaged in research and discourse in the area of African Traditional Culture. He has written books, contributed chapters in academic and research volumes, as well as published in different academic journals. His current research interest includes bioethical issues in African Traditional Medicine and this has earned him a Fellow of the Bayreuth Academy of Advanced African Studies (BA). His interest falls within the Knowledge and Morality Research Section of the ACC. He takes a particular interest in the religion and culture of Africans. Oluwatoyin Olokodana-James, Ph.D., is a prolific scholar, dancer, choreographer and three-time recipient of the Lagos State Scholarship Award from the Lagos State Government (2008-2011). She is a lecturer in the Department of Creative Arts, University of Lagos. Her research interests are in African Studies with a special focus on Dance Ethnography, Gender Identity Studies, Film Studies and Criticism. Dr. Olokodana- James is also an Associate Fellow of the Institute of African Diaspora Studies (IADS), University of Lagos and Member/Principal Investigator of the African Multiple Cluster Centre of Excellence, Bayreuth, Germany. iv IADS Cluster: Gender, Culture and Identity (Team Lead) Idongesit Eshiet, Ph.D., is a Sociologist with a research focus on Gender and Development Studies. Dr. Eshiet is an astute researcher who has participated in many local and international research projects. Her work on ‘Voice and Accountability in the Primary Healthcare Sector in Nigeria’, which argues for good health governance through civic engagement, won the 1st Prize of the Belinda and Bill Gates Foundation sponsored Writing Fellowship Award on ‘Investing in Human Capital as an Effective Strategy for National Development in Nigeria’ (2019). Dr. Eshiet is an alumnus of Brown International Advanced Research Institute, Brown University, Providence, Rhodes Island, USA, where she was exposed to a Comparative Analysis of Development Theory and Practice in the global North and South. This experience has broadened her horizon on development issues and as well impacted her research and teaching skills. She is also a Laureate of the Council for the Development of Social Science Research in Africa (CODESRIA). Dr. Eshiet has participated and read her works at various conferences both locally and internationally and has published extensively both locally and internationally. Cooperating Partner (Calabar, Nigeria) Merab Yta Edisua, Ph.D., is a development consultant, an academic, a foremost Children’s Theatre practitioner in the South-South Zone, a leading development communication NGO activist, a writer, director, performing artist, storyteller, researcher, applied theatre facilitator and church leader. She is a leader and member of many associations, NGOs and Networks. Her skills and areas of interest span Gender, SBCC programming, Tourism, Applied Theatre, Entertainment Education. At present, she is an alumnus of UNDP LDP in Nigeria and has completed the West African Capacity Transfer v Intensive (WACTI) and leads leadership training for UNDP at National and International levels. Research Assistants (IADS Cluster: Gender, Culture and Identity) Kehinde Samuel Olukayode is a doctoral student at the Department of English, University of Lagos, Nigeria. He holds a master’s degree from the same department. His research interests are Theatre & Performance, African Popular Culture, Cultural Studies and Media Studies. Some of his papers have been published or are awaiting publication in reputed journals. Abbas Aremu Rahman is an Assistant Lecturer in the Department of Art & Social Sciences Education, University of Lagos. He is currently a PhD student pursuing a doctoratein Education (Teaching and Learning of Islamic Studies) in the same university. His research interests include educational theories and pedagogy. Amenaghawon Idawu (nee Abusomwan) holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in English & Literature; Advanced Diploma in Early Childhood Education; Master of Arts degree in English Language, and Master of Arts degree in African & Diaspora Studies. She has authored and co-authored academic papers through cutting-edge research and scholarly ideation. Blessing Chidiebere Emodi is an educationist with a specialisation in Igbo Language. She has her Nigeria Certificate in Education (NCE Igbo/English) 2009; B.Ed. Igbo in 2015; Master’s in Education (Igbo, 2018); and a Ph.D. in view. Over the years, Emodi has taught as a Class Teacher, Subject Teacher and university lecturer. Her interests include integrating technology and Igbo teaching. She is currently an Assistant Lecturer at the University of Lagos. vi PREFACE This project was hatched in one of the working sessions of the Gender, Culture and Identity Research Cluster of the Institute of African and Diaspora Studies (IADS). The IADS was established in 2017 with a vision ‘to become an Institute for exchange of cultural and social ideas and research excellence in pursuit of knowledge for the development of Africa, the African Diaspora and the world.’ Since then, the IADS has created a platform for researchers to engage in critical reflection. In 2019, the IADS became a home to the Lagos-African Cluster Centre (ACC). The researchers of IADS were admitted into the Cluster as Principal Investigators assigned to the Lagos-ACC, which is one of the four ACCs in Africa. The ACCs are directly linked to the African Multiple Cluster of Excellence, University of Bayreuth. The Principal Investigators in the Lagos-ACC have won different grants from the Cluster of Excellence as well as the Lagos-ACC. This project, ‘Re-examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity in Nigeria: The Fattening Room Tradition of the Efik’, is one of such projects that won a grant from the Lagos-ACC. vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The research team wishes to express gratitude to the Cluster and in particular the Director of the Lagos-ACC, Prof. Muyiwa Falaiye, for considering this project good enough for funding after following all due processes. The team is grateful to the Cooperating partner, Dr. Merab Edisua of the University of Calabar, for doing all the groundwork and identifying respondents for the project. The respondents are quite important to the execution of this project and we appreciate their significant contributions and are grateful for their consent and approval to use their contributions in this work. We also duly acknowledge the immense support of Prof. Bernard Sorre during the process of analysis. Dr. Abiodun Bello was significantly and effectively helpful with the proofreading, vetting and quality assurance of the final report. On behalf of the team, I thank everyone who contributed in various dimensions for their critique and input. This we indeed consider a good prelude to more research. And finally, I want to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under the German Excellence Strategy – EXC 2052/1 – 390713894 for funding this first edition through the African Multiple Cluster of Excellence. Introduction 1 INTRODUCTION The African universe is typically one whole interconnected commune of existence. Just as the world of the living, the dead and the unborn connect in a transcendental manner, the flora and fauna are closely connected to the general and overarching cognition of the natural African person. It is in this very sense that ‘we are what we eat’, an idea that reflects the significance of dietary content to people’s general well-being and sociocultural outlook. For the Africans, therefore, food is life! By extension, in the circle and context of education, we can equally posit that ‘we are what we are taught and what we read’. To this end, the very essence of the Fattening Room practice among the Efik is to make women into what the society wants them to be. In this outlook to life and the world, the rites of passage through the cyclicity of life must be unbroken. Different commentaries already show that, as far as connubial relations are concerned, an average Efik woman has the requisite native education and training needed to hold onto a man and make a lasting home. For a long time, society, especially outside her natal context, has described the Efik woman as ‘promiscuous' based on these qualities. But such commentaries are, to a large extent, a reflection of assumptions that are based on a long history of socialisation and far-reaching popular orientation, often based on what people outside the Efik culture were taught. In the fattening room, an Efik woman is groomed and moulded to know how to care for her prospective husband and what it takes to look after her future home. If learning takes place properly and is practised by the book, men who encounter such women as possessing this orientation, are most likely to fall in love with them. This mix of acquired values and public disparagement Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 2 form the background for the research into the Fattening Room Culture of the Efik people. Regrettably, the fattening room practice among the Efik is fast waning. The field trip confirmed that the practice is weakening and disappearing, thus giving this work very strategic importance. This is because essential information disappears with a waning culture. The findings of this study show that, while the practice in its entirety is not extremely bad, some aspects of the practice, such as female circumcision or female genital mutilation (FGM), that the government has banned, make the practice important to examine and evaluate in a research context. In the main, there are four reasons the fattening room practice is found to be waning. First is the classification of female circumcision as a criminal offence. The second reason is the perceived not-too-healthy act of overfeeding the bride or the maiden in the fattening room. The third reason is the traditional length of time for which maidens are expected to stay in the fattening room, which varies from one month to seven years, while the fourth is the fact that many have linked the Anansa river goddess and Egbe ritual to the fattening room practice. This has occasioned a reality in which many who are Christians are seen to frown at the age-old fattening room practice, considering it as evil and fetish. However, respondents tend to appreciate what can be learned in the fattening room. Some described it as a school where a lady is moulded into a good mother, a wife, a person with an overall good character, and one that is attractive to men. For these reasons, all the respondents think highly of the fattening room practice, but wish for some constructive and progressive adjustment. Introduction 3 This research is distinctive because it is a blend of three different views. The first group represents the older generation who supports the practice of the fattening room as it is presently done because they feel it is a longstanding tradition of the Efik. The second group comprises mostly members of the younger generation who applaud the focus of the fattening room practice with significant adjustment and elimination of some needless parts of the practice. They also requested the possibility of upgrading the programme into a formal curriculum, where ladies can go and learn voluntarily to become better persons, whether married or not. More so, they are of the opinion that a similar programme or rite should be developed for men to prepare them for marriages. The third group represents a few members of the community who do not support the practice of the fattening room at all. These are of the opinion that there are other possible ways by which a woman can be taught the basic things to prepare her for marriage. The third group is perceptibly hostile to the idea of the fattening room practice in its entirety because they perceive it from the point of view of gender imbalance. As a result, they ask questions such as: Why should it be a woman? Who is preparing the man for the woman? Why should only women be prepared for household chores? What is the place of the woman in the society? Why should a woman’s body be made to become appealing to a man? What are the health concerns that go with being very fat? These questions describe the concerns of the third group. This report, which assumes a deliberate polyphonic approach, represents field data gathered in view of laid-out objectives for the project. The study examined the core notions of culture, morality, and femininity among the Efik, as exemplified in the fattening room practice. The study addresses the existing Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 4 knowledge gap by going beyond earlier studies on the advantages and disadvantages of the fattening room practice among the Efik people, to observing the fattening room tradition, highlighting the content of the learning processes, evaluating the practice, and examining its heuristic value. These were done against the backdrop of the changing notions of femininity, gender roles, and identity in contemporary times. The multivocal style of the report provides an adequate ground for the researchers to strengthen the voice of respondents and interviewees in a manner that underscores the role of gender and gender perception from the perspectives of direct cultural actors in the context of the Efik fattening room tradition. Methodology This is a nine-month research that included fieldwork in Calabar, in southern Nigeria. The first part of this project had researchers engage in library studies to review literature. Discoveries at this stage of the study showed that the fattening room practice among the Efik was waning. After the literature review, the Principal Investigators (PIs) and the research team conducted a field trip to Calabar with the purpose of collecting data for a documentary on fattening room practices and to carry out Key Informant Interviews and focus group discussions with people who had either experienced, or contributed to the fattening room practice. To achieve the objective of the research, researchers worked with a Cooperative Partner who is female and knowledgeable in the Efik tradition, and the Calabar environment. This Cooperative Partner helped to identify Key Informants. The In- depth and Key Informant Interview methods were used to elicit responses from practitioners of the fattening room practice. Eighteen (18) In-depth Interviews were conducted in the following categories: six (6) maidens; four (4) parents and two (2) caregivers who attend to the maidens; six (6) Key Informants Introduction 5 who are knowledgeable about the fattening room practice both from historical and contemporary points of view and reside in the locations in which the study would be carried out. There were two Focus Group Discussions (FGD); one with male participants to get the male perspective, and the second with female participants for the female perspective. The documentary part of the project was made possible through a re-enactment of the fattening room practice. The researchers had the challenge of observing an ongoing fattening room practice because the practice is fast waning among the Efik due to the influence of modernity. However, this challenge was overcome through the documentary part of the project where the fattening room practice was re-enacted with the help of the Cooperative Partner. The fieldwork lasted for 10 days, after which the researchers and the Research Assistants in Lagos, analysed the data collected. The data collected were analysed in accordance with the research objectives. This is provided in the Digital Research Environment of the Cluster/Lagos-ACC. The documentary that shares the title of this report is part of the data that were collected and analysed. Research Objectives This section is focused on the analysis of the data collected from the field during the study. The main purpose of the study is to examine Gender, Gender Roles and Identity in Africa, with a focus on the fattening room tradition native to the Efik people of Nigeria. However, there are five (5) specific objectives that will be responded to using the data gathered from the field. These specific objectives include: 1. To investigate the language, symbols, rituals, and shared meanings that characterise the fattening room practice among the Efik. The researchers set out to find out the languages, symbols, rituals and shared meanings that Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 6 characterise the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria. 2. To identify the learning models used in the fattening room practice of the Efik. The researchers asked, ‘What learning models are used in the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria?’ 3. To show the multiplicity of knowledge in gender, gender roles, and identity among Africans. Researchers wanted to identify the multiplicities of knowledge (childbearing, homecare, cooking, sexuality, health, etc.) derived from the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria. The content of the learning processes was derived from interviews. 4. To produce a narrative of the fattening room practice of the Efik against the backdrop of deducing a theory on gender, gender role, and identity in Africa. This objective generate the question: Can a theory on gender, gender role and identity in Africa be deduced based on the narratives of the Fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria? 5. To contribute to the Cluster-Knowledge Lab on gender, gender roles and identity in Africa. To achieve this objective, researchers asked questions around gender, gender roles and identity in Africa. At any rate, researchers found this study important because contemporary discourses on gender are dominated by Western views of femininity and masculinity that currently challenge the traditional notions on gender and gender roles in Africa. Nevertheless, since every culture has a clear understanding of gender and gender roles, which help in shaping the identity of individuals in their societies, it is important that such diversity of views in gender discourse be given equal prominence in scholarship, especially in Africa as a continent notable for multiple cultures and gender notions. Introduction 7 The findings aid the reflexive aspect of the project by juxtaposing the multiple positions on gender with contemporary ideas from the West with the view to a better appreciation of the strength and structure of gender and identity development among Africans. At the same time, the study self-evaluates the existing African positions on gender, gender roles and identity and consequently produces balanced positions that are better apprehended as a sociocultural dialogue rather than an uncoordinated ethnological and discursive formation on African cultural practices in particular and the African world at large. Data and Discussion Based on Research Objectives As already stated, this study is mapped out and coordinated based on a research focus that has been outlined into strategic research objectives. These are systematically worked out into a well-tailored field report as represented in the subsequent sections of this discourse. Objective 1: To investigate the language, symbols, rituals, and shared meanings that characterise the fattening room practice among the Efik. The researchers set out to find out the languages, symbols, rituals and shared meanings that characterise the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria. Findings: Findings from the study show that the fattening room practices among the Efik are characterised by shared meanings, languages, symbols and rituals. This is to the extent that cultures are generally transmissible by learning behaviours that make them sustainable from one generation to another through established processes of socialisation, including rites of passage. As such, the objective of the fattening room is to make the girl child go through a rite of passage that acquaints and empowers Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 8 her with life skills, such as home management skills, relational skills, self-care, etiquettes and good manners, among other teachable skills and cultural ways. In the process of teaching cultural ethos and virtues to maidens in the fattening room, the caregiver devises a special language and a set of symbols of communication with participants. All the participants in the Focus Group Discussion with women agreed that ‘…there are special languages used in the fattening room.’ In the words of Respondent 4 (R4), ‘…I can tell now but those languages are symbolic and you can’t get it anywhere [others are in agreement].’ Respondent 1 (R1) mentioned ‘nsibidi’ as an example of a special language used. According to R4, ‘… The hairdo carries a specially made comb from brass...and on that comb, there are some signs written on it, those are the nsibidi symbols.’ R2 mentioned that ‘the hairdo for adiagha, who is the first daughter, is different from that of the second daughter; and …the hairdo styles are different types.’ In addition, during the fattening room practice, maidens engage in certain ritual activities that help define the fattening room rite of passage among the Efik. Ritual is taken to mean actions and activities that are done repeatedly and women are said to be a part of the ritual process in the Efik kingdom. In the remark of Respondent 2: As far as I know, being in Duke Town Church where the English coronations of Efik kings are done, I discovered years back during the coronation of Edidem Iye Ephraim Adam that it is a woman that pours the Mmong Emem (Water of Peace) on the Edidem (King). I also knew [at] that time that the last insult the Edidem receives (marking the last time anybody can insult the Edidem for Introduction 9 the rest of his lifetime) is the Ikong Edidem Eti, and that is also done by a woman (FGDM, R2). In agreement with this remark, Respondent 4 added that: My brothers have already said a lot in this matter, but I also want to bring in one other point. Efik people love beautiful things. In the government of the Efik, we believe in Oku Ndem, the overall power. The Mbiam Nfat (the juju makers) were the messengers and implementors [sic] of what the Oku Ndem said. The Oku Ndem were people from the water. Those that travelled to the waters saw how beautiful the people there were. So, when they came out of the water, they tried to make their daughters as beautiful as the people [in] the marine world because, if your child was accepted by Ndem, she would be rated higher. The process of making her that beautiful is to take her through this process and preparation… [He however asserts] But first and foremost, we are descendants of the Jews and we take from God’s instruction that circumcision is a must, but we here do it to both male and female… But because the people from Ndem usually prefer female to male children, our people beautify the female child to look as closely beautiful as possible to the girls in the marine world so they can be acceptable to the men in the marine world. That beautification happens in the fattening room… (FGDM, R4). As an attempt to aid an understanding of the rituals in the nkuho tradition, R4 further identified some of the underlying reasons for the tradition in these words: Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 10 The first phase of nkuho is to make the girl-child know all that she needs to know about managing a household, proper behaviour, etiquettes, etc. The last phase gives her the final preparation and releases her to practice the things that she has learnt (FGD MEN, R4). Another participant who agreed with the above comments also passionately added her own assertion, that: Though I pass through it, right? But I think it was a rite of passage, preparing you to become a woman. Because I think that their belief was that before a girl child is sent out, she should be well cultured (FGD WOMEN, P4). As observed, the nkuho happens before marriage and some of the women explained part of the ritual that usually takes place before the marriage in nkuho. I think [that], about a week before my marriage, I was just not allowed to go out, friends could not come to see me and I have a senior matron or relative, somebody in the family and they [would] just bring food for me to eat and then they [would] massage me with the traditional ointment (FGD WOMEN, P3). Another participant in this group, in a rejoinder, added the following comment: Yes, I will answer that question, if you call that ritual because, in the house, you are being confined. Nobody comes in there except your caregiver. And, on the door, there is this soft palm front, like [a] fresh, one and they Introduction 11 put it there; that is, to give the information to some other person that someone is inside that room and nobody should come in there. So, if you call that a ritual, I will agree with you (FGD WOMEN, P4). On marriage and its related rituals, Idi who had participated in the nkuho shared a broader perspective on the subject of marriage to complement the contributions of other participants in the group: R: Right at that teenage age, a suitor or a family might eye you as [that point] and decide to come notify the family, ‘We are interested in this girl [just] in case you would want us to [have] her hand in marriage.’ That is 'nkuho eyen owon'. After that, you will be removed... That is the rite of passage for the girl. I: Okay R: And it is agreed that, at that time, you don't know what a man is, right! I: Okay. R: It is from that age of 15 or 16, that they will now mutilate your female genital organ... After that..., now you've entered your rite of passage, and you are proceeding to become an adult, right!? I: Okay R: At the age of 18, this suitor who has already indicated interest, the family now would have started making a move into coming to ask your parents for your hands in marriage. That’s where the real nkuho now comes in because you have to stay another year… it could be two or three or more depending on how capable your parents are to keep you in the house, feed you ... because you don't have anything to do [other] than to eat and sleep (P 1). Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 12 It is important to note that, during the above discussion on the recurring subject of nkuho, the subject of female circumcision during the rites also came to the fore. As far as the general cultural awareness of the participants goes, the rite was incomplete without the circumcision ritual: Before I was put into the fattening room, in fact, I was circumcised, Yes! And that was the first stage. (FGD WOMEN, P2). While explaining the process of the circumcision, it was further highlighted that: … then you go to the backyard where they have plantain trees. They cut some fresh plantain leaves which they use as a mat for you to lie naked. Your legs are held by two people, then a native nurse comes with scissors and a razor, after which they massage the clitoris to make it soft before cutting it (Maiden, 1). On the part of the caregiver, the following explain the question on how to become a caregiver, if there was an initiation process: I: ... is there any sort of initiation that these caregivers would have to go through? We are not talking about forbidden [things] now... R: No no no no no..., there is initiation I: No ritual processes? R: No ritual processes. There is practically nothing... They just look at you as an elderly woman, that you have the traditional knowledge; they pick you. It all boils down to you accepting… your interest (P. 1). Introduction 13 On shared meaning during the fattening room process, the researchers noted with interest the following point as articulated by one of the participants: I want to agree to a large extent with what you have said. In a way, when you look at it with the lenses of gender, yes! When they go into this fattening, they are told this is what you must do: as a woman, you must be submissive to your husband; this is what you must do to your in-laws, and things like that. Not as if they really train them to be confident and free. Then, another aspect of the fattening room which we have not mentioned here is the circumcision aspect (FGD WOMEN, P.3). No, it is just a notice that somebody is in the house, and their belief too, depending on the family. It used to be believed that if a lizard or wall gecko came in and peeped [during the circumcision rite], it would reduce your body or the flesh so that, no matter how [they] ate, they wouldn’t get the curves that they wanted. So they put that [i.e. leaves from the plantain sucker]. Some used to put a grass that is nkim enang and they tied it with half-burnt firewood and [kept] it by the door, so that in case anybody – an elderly woman might want to come and see you or your mother friend may want to come and see you. In case they have any bad intentions or negativity, it will be neutralised. (FGD WOMEN, P4). Providing clarification, another participant added: No! It was just for you as a girl-child… your pride [P2 re-echoes ‘your pride’] and for the family; just your pride. If you come out, you will look down on other girls that have not gone through that process as if they are not your mate (FGD WOMEN, P4). Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 14 Yes, it gives complexity to the other girls. Because you need to see how this ceremony is, especially [on the day the maiden is coming out]. It is usually a big festival [where] the whole people will gather. So it gives you that confidence and class (FGD WOMEN, P1) ... I think a normal Efik girl will be proud if she is put in a fattening house and taught how to cook. Some don’t even know how to cook what we call edikan Ikong soup because there is [a] difference between edikan Ikong and vegetable soup [other participants concur]. So a girl will be happy if she is taught how to cook these special delicacies of the Efik – what edikan ikong really is, so those practices can continue. But let the circumcision be removed because it was not a palatable experience [Three participants agreed that the circumcision should not be included but P2 believes it should still be part of the fattening room tradition] (FGD WOMEN, P4). I don’t think it is completely going out because most people now cannot just do the wedding without doing the traditional [wedding] and in the traditional [wedding] you will go through some of those things (FGD WOMEN, P1). Out of experience yes, because most times you are not hungry and you are forced to eat. The early morning food that is garri soaked overnight [Others agree and laugh] to make it soft and they put plenty [of] water in it, and it is given to you to drink and you are tired of it, but you are forced to drink it because they want your curves to come out. It is believed that if you are well-fed, your curves will come out and your body will be glittering and that one has not finished. Around 10 or 11am, they bring Introduction 15 you another one and this is … sometimes ekpang or ortor in a big tray again. That aspect was not very sweet [All agree] (FGD WOMEN, P4.) No! It did not. The 12 pounds remain the 12 pounds and all the item mmin ukung usung (drinks for knocking door), mmin akan (drinks for prayer), mmin ekom (drinks for greeting)… Everything remains the same till today, nothing has changed. It is just the greedy parents these days. Even then, there was nothing like mkpo ete (gifts for father). It was strictly mkpo eka (gifts for mother). But, as we speak now, mkpo ete is even higher than mkpo eka. They will just give mkpo eka peanut, except the groom's family are rich that they will now enhance mkpo eka. But mkpo ete is up there [meaning on a high side] (KII, 2). For the nkuho, like I told us earlier, we have nkuho in three stages. The early one is to keep the child on point, make her focus. You know education was by the way. But, when the Whites came in, it was pertinent that the girl-child should go to school. That is why circumcision at that school-age – that is, 7 to 8 years – was very pertinent, very very popular. As at that time, it was just to do the circumcision (KII, 5). Yes, it was then year 6 or 7. The child was expected to start Elementary One. There was this general belief that we all have feelings, that even a child has feelings and they were careful not to let somebody touch the child in an unpleasant place so that she would not feel anything. There was this belief that once circumcision is done, all feelings are gone. And some married women then suffered it because they were denied what it means [to Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 16 have] feelings for your husband. They were denied what it means for a woman to cum when she is having sex with her husband. They were denied all that. All they knew was just go in there, do the needful to become a mother. But to enjoy sex? Zero (KII, 4). At nkuho preparing you for ndo (marriage), you will be taught all these things [that] we have mentioned. But, for making you an akwa nwan (full woman), it is expected of us that, as we are sending out our daughter, we are not just selling her, so that no husband tomorrow will ask you, ‘When you came, what did you come with? [From] everything in this house, show me what you came with.’ Not from our tribe. From our tribe here, [when] sending you off, we are sending you off fully. They will give you a full parlour setting. They will give you a kitchen set. They will give you a full-room setting as you are going to your husband’s house and they will give you good money. Good money [has been] seen inside the seclusion room. So everybody that goes into the seclusion room – in fact, the girl in question that is secluded – has been taught and given something to say if she dares sights it: ‘nnugho mbe nnugho,’ meaning, ‘monitoring spirit I monitor you first’ [laughter]. Because it is believed that the wall gecko is coming to take everything that the girl has eaten, … so once the girl sees it or if anybody that is there sights it, they will make that exclamation. So, culturally, like most of the cultural artefacts are brought out on the outing ceremony to decorate the nkuho’s seat... Most of the artefacts there, depending on the family – like in my royal home, we will bring out our golden gong, our golden panes, our silver spoons, our canon. My father had a canon that was used in fighting the war. Our artefacts from years of slave trade, the palm Introduction 17 fronts, the [golds] that were collected during the early stage, depending on the family. Sometimes families borrow. You can borrow from some other families [artefacts such as] golden lanterns, the traditional long guns, the Dane guns, heads of Carmel, heads of lions that [a family member] had killed. And this differs from one family to another. So families do borrow these things to enrich their canopies. So it all depends on what you want to showcase, depending on your level of affluence (KII, 2). Based on these complex preparations, a family that has any interest in a maiden being already groomed and now wants her as a wife in their family, may now go into possible pre-nuptial negotiations with the maiden’s family, often without her knowledge. This is the second stage in the chain of processes. In the third process, once the maiden in question has been removed from the traditional fattening home, she goes to the church dressed in her gown. The day after is usually the market day and the lady is dressed in another attire as she makes a public appearance on such a day. Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 18 Plate 1: A maiden freshly out of the fattening room The participant provides a further description of that occasion in this narrative manner: Introduction 19 They now take her to the market... because she has to go through the market. People have to appreciate the work [the efforts] of her parents – how they were able to feed her, massage her [and] how beautiful now she looks… Oh! She has now become...she is going to be a woman. And the suitor there now has seen [her] and he's happy. People now come... keep giving her many gifts – many gifts – all the apparatus, and even the food- stuff, right! And then she goes back to the fattening room to now become a woman for the next four years making seven good years. So, she stays there and learns whatever trade... My grandmother was a seamstress. It was inside there that they taught her how to cut and sew. Then it was [the era of] the hand-sewing machine. There [were no leg-pedaled] machines. So, they bring the [maiden] there. She goes out to learn to cut and sew and they have all these crocheting [designs and patterns] … they teach her how to crochet all that... what [designs] she'll be doing to put in the back chair... These antimacassars in the chairs and on the table... Illustrating this further, the participant provided more details: Like now that we have the Obong, right? You know the queen... Except if she wants to go to the kitchen, she has everything there. There are housekeepers. There are maidens who do everything. So, in the case of my grandmother, there were so many slaves in the compound who did everything for her and the mother. So, except there is a particular food the father wants to eat, it is then the mother enters the kitchen to supervise the cooking. And as a queen, you want her to come and sit and train her child? So, she has somebody who is capable of doing Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 20 that. She employs that person. That's when the caregiver comes in. The caregiver is well taken care of. The king has a lot of things. Is it money or wealth? The caregiver is well taken care of monetary wise and wealth wise... Assuming you are put in a fattening room, and you have an arrangement between you, your caregiver and your suitor or your male friend...and you are inside your fattening room – remember you've been circumcised so it's a license now that you can have fun or have sex – and maybe your caregiver is not around, your parents are not around, and your guy sneaks in and in the process, you become pregnant – when your caregiver notices that you are pregnant, you will not stay up to the day that you are supposed to, and the traditional rite of bringing you out, putting you on the podium for people to watch, to come and give you gifts will not be there. They will expel you from the fattening room (IDI, 1). This is the extent to which the nkuho traditional practices can be adjudged to be self-regulating and self-correcting. Of Symbols and Meaning in the Context of the Fattening Room The distinct context of the fattening room inscribes within its space the presence of special symbols which also encode in themselves meanings that are understood only within this interpretive community by participants. These could have loose meanings and at other times may be complex. Participants in the Focus Group Discussion recalled and rehashed some of these ideas as presented further: Sorry, I want to disagree because I don’t think they stay that long in the fattening room and there is a certain age Introduction 21 when you are 12 or 14 when you are approaching puberty, you don’t stay there up to a year in the fattening room and then the issue of circumcision is not a problem [some participants disagrees] (FGD WOMEN, P2). Some people do it – as I attended a traditional marriage in London. You need to see the processes even in London. People were telling them how to dress [even there] in London and it was a beautiful experience and it gave this empowerment you are talking about in all ramifications and is giving you self-pride and confidence and I was so proud of it. I took pictures and I said, Ah! So this thing can be taken to London. It is good (FGD WOMEN, P1). [The speaker chuckles] You know at that age I was told and I did not understand and I went through it, and like she said the pampering, everything, the care, you were taught how to do this and that (FGD WOMEN, P2). Yes! Because they want your curves to come out when you come out of the fattening room you will be figure 8. (FGD WOMEN, P4). ...we call it ‘uwang idem’ because, while you are there, you don’t wear clothes. Just a little piece on your waist they call it ‘mkpin’ and since your boobs have started coming, there is a small piece tied on your boobs region (FGD WOMEN, P4). It is assumed that if you wear clothes, it ties your body and you will not be as fat as they want. So, you won’t wear it so that you will be free and, as the massage is going on, you will give them what they want (FGD WOMEN, P4). Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 22 I think it is a common one. You use your ‘ofong-ukot anwan’ (something like women’s pants/trousers), the beads – all those things are symbolic. And I am ‘oduwan’, that is, the second daughter and there is a bead for that and hairstyle and for the ‘adiagha’ too – she has a special bead and hairstyle, depending on your position in the family (FGD WOMEN, P2). Yes! While they were in the fattening room, the nkuho attendants could use the white cloth to give a certain design [shows the interviewer the symbol] – this serpentine movement that, as you are leaving this fattening room, life is not a straightforward thing. Life is not a bed of roses. As you are going out there if you think marriage is just a straight line thing – no, marriage has so many challenges and those challenges were interpreted with this [shows the symbol again]; so don’t expect any straight line pattern of life in your marriage. You will see curves all over and when those curves come you have to develop a thick skin to withstand them so that your marriage will stand. That is one. Two, the flowery pattern on their faces, teaches them that you must always package yourself, not [only] when you are seen. You were a sweet-looking girl. But just [by] one drop, you turn yourself to ekaeka (i.e. grandmother or old woman). From there your husband that was not supposed to be looking outside when he comes back you are there tying a wrapper on your boobs. You have now turned into an old woman – no! Still, maintain yourself and your husband will not go looking right, left, back, and front. And they do that through the facial design [which they] make on them. And you talked about the brass trays. Most of those designs are also encrypted on the brass plates that you use in serving guests when they come – Introduction 23 that you use in decorating your house. All of them have codes of love, codes of fairness about life, codes of being straightforward in life, codes of harmonisation in life. Without these codes [as they will teach you] you may not really succeed in life and your marriage (KII, 5). I heard, ‘Marine, marine, marine,’ in the morning. I did not want to interfere, because what they brought in was bringing in ekanem-abasi (name of Efik marine deity) into ndo (marriage). We are Efiks and we know Anansa Ndem Iboku, Ekanem Abasi Ibodio – they are all spirits that... They are seers. If a king is about to be nominated, Ekpenyong Odusu, Ekanem Abasi, in particular, Ekanem Ibodio are consulted. [So and so name] has been nominated for enthronement. Is he qualified? Those are the duties of Ekanem Abasi; that is one. On the other hand, if the parents have stayed there five years, seven years, ten years, fifteen years and there is no child and they decided to consult Ekpenyong Abasi and they consulted Ekpenyong Abasi and Akanem Abasi in the power that God has given her was able to manipulate and help them have a child. These deities will not give [to] you and you just go away. You must return to them. So that is where those things come to play. But, in the free ones, no, no. And those deities – the good ones – are like guidance angels. We have guidance angels in the church. We have prophetesses in these newborn churches, the likes of Father Mbaka. They are all everywhere. They will tell you it is like this, it will be like that, it will happen like this. Those are the roles of Ekpenyong Abasi… (KII, 5). Everything is symbolic. In the coming-out ceremony, for instance, [with respect to] the Efik hairdo, there is the Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 24 one that is done for the ‘adiagha’, that is the first daughters. There is the one that is done for the second daughters. In the coming-out ceremony, this hair that they have there is a length for the first daughter. There is a length for the second daughter. So you dare not make the mistake of giving the firstborn a shorter hair or the second daughter a longer length. Considering the number of combs also, the first daughter has seven combs; the second daughter cannot have more than five combs from four, three down, [but] not more than five, you know. So they are all very symbolic. For the dance the coming-out costume itself. The short rapper that is tied – the mmpin as you call it, or the oyonyo that you wear – will all show that day whether you [are] betrothed or not betrothed. For instance, if the nkuho girl comes out with a longer oyonyo, it means that, before she went into the fattening room, somebody had already betrothed her. So, you can’t see all [of] her – you know everything she has to offer – again. You can only see as much as you can see because somebody had already betrothed her. But, if she has not been betrothed, she will tie just the other small clothes on her waist and chest so that you can still admire her and get desires. So everything is symbolic. The songs are symbolic (KII, 2). After that, they come every morning to dress you up. They use the native pot, the small one, which they heat and add oil, then water and something else. When this mixture is ready, they use a chicken feather to dip in and rub you, instead of their hands. After they have used warm water to massage the wound, they use the chicken feather, dipped in palm oil to put on the surface of the wound (Maiden 1). Introduction 25 To these extents, it can be seen that the language, symbols, rituals, and shared meanings as inscribed within the fattening room practice, are not simplistic in their significations, as they indeed constitute important cultural aspects that engender internal cohesion and coherence for the native Efik people. Objective 2 In this section, the main focus is to identify the learning models used in the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria. The researchers asked ‘what learning models are used in the Fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria?’ Generally, the learning models of the fattening room stems from the informal educational tradition, where nothing [like a] curriculum or timetable is scheduled for the teachings. The teachings and learning are basically [apprenticeship-like] in approach. The subject matters, including moral, health, homecare and similar teachings, are vocationally inclined – this is, the learning models that pervade the findings. Identification of [the vocational method] as the general learning model is evident in the response of a member of the men’s focus group discussion. He explained: Just like it has been said earlier, where you have all forms of vocational training, she is trained on how to dance, how to cook, how to make beads and mats and other crafts plus many other training including behaviour and proper interaction with people and how to plan for [her] future (FGDM, R1). Following the nature of the vocational method of teaching, everything was learnt by doing and practising. A participant in Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 26 the female focus group discussion, who is also a maiden – that is, a ‘graduate’ of the fattening room – gave the details in this manner: So, in my own case, the caregiver really took time to teach me how to prepare the ekpang. You have to grate the cocoyam so that it does not stain your hands. She tells you if it does. ‘What if your husband happens to pass by and sees you and all your hands are messed up with cocoyam?’ He might decide not to eat that food because he will feel that you were not well-groomed. So you have to make sure that those things do not come into play. And they show you how to tie it with cocoyam leaves and how you place it in the pot. You are shown what you have to put first under the pot, what you put in the middle and then when to put crayfish, when to put fish and when to put oil. You sit down and watch how they are doing it (Maiden 1). Also, some of the teaching and learning were artistic in nature. This model is a form of vocational training that involves storytelling, teaching of proverbs, singing, dancing, attire dressing, carving and weaving. This was made known by a male Key Informant in his response that: In the fattening room ... there is a lot of storytelling, especially at the first stage. They teach them songs [sings in efik dialect – Ekpe ino ebot mi, mmangha ti mmagimag] at that level. So that is where we have storytelling... ( KII: 5). This submission was also affirmed by a female Key Informant: Introduction 27 So, you are taken through all that process and it is very artistic. And the way and manner she does whatever she is doing – the massage is very artistic (KII, 4). Complementing the learning models used are the various types of knowledge received in the fattening room. These are discussed in the next objective. Objective 3 In this section, the objective is to show the multiplicity of knowledge in gender, gender roles, and identity among Africans, in this instance as enshrined in the cultural practices of the Efik. Researchers wanted to identify the multiplicities of knowledge (for instance, about childbearing, home care, cooking, sexuality, health, etc.) derived from the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria. The contents of the learning processes were derived from interviews. The findings revealed that a multiplicity of knowledge was received in the fattening room. This is analysed and presented under such discrete themes as childbearing and motherhood, home care, cooking, sexuality, health, skills, and morality. Childbearing and Motherhood Childbearing and motherhood in the context of the fattening room are characterised by teachings on the art of mothering. It involves the care of self and that of the baby – How to put the baby to sleep, bathing of the baby, breastfeeding, and the teaching of the children – forms the basic knowledge under childbearing or motherhood. This could be inferred from the responses from the female Key Informants, two of whom explained, in part, that: Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 28 There is an aspect that, when you become a mother, there are certain things you must do. Of course, you have to keep your baby clean. Apart from your own personal hygiene, the children must be clean. You must teach your children how to respect elders. So it is all part of it. A mother should be able to impact that knowledge on her child (KII, 2). And the other: … so that the storehouse will never deplete. So, the most important part of that seclusion process is the social education, the social character moulding where the women selected to do this work will be coming every day to teach her how to breastfeed a child. They will be checking her weight, how to carry a baby (KII, 5). Nkuho, therefore, like many other African traditions, underscores the importance of adequate preparation or preparedness for motherhood as well as the roles that come with it. Homecare Homecare is another form of knowledge in the fattening room. This is all about the management of home and house chores as explained by a member of the male focus group discussants: It is all about training your daughter or girl-child on home management, to be able to cater for her home when she gets married to her husband. In the fattening room, she will be taught how to run home chores (FGDM, R3). Homecare teaching involves how to make the home neatly [and make it] properly arranged. The clothes in the bedroom must not Introduction 29 be scattered all over. The sitting room must also be accommodating. Visitors should find one’s home open and hospitable. A key informant and focus group discussant elucidated: When your in-law comes around, this is how to treat them. When they come, welcome them. Always have food. Your home should be a home where your door is always open and people are always welcome. You know those kinds of thoughts (FGDW, R3). Two, they also teach them how to cater for [their] home. You don’t scatter things. Your [living room] must look good. Your bedroom must be good. Your husband’s bed must look clean – the bed sheet clean, everywhere clean, fine smell [good] (KII, 5). Also, care of the husband is one core [aspect] of homecare. Cooking for the husband and the children; getting bathing water for the husband; setting the table and kind treatment of one’s husband are homecare contents. Some of the maidens interviewed revealed their experiences in this regard: I have said it. I [learnt] how to cook [from] inside there. I [learnt] how to take care of my husband. Nobody [taught] me. I learnt it there and … it is making my marriage sweet (Maiden 2) ...They will teach you when you leave here and go to your husband’s house, how to welcome him... In the morning, how you put water for him to wash his hands, wash his face, small things [like] you putting a chewing stick for him to chew, [washing] his mouth and how you keep water for him to bath (Maiden 2). Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 30 Accordingly, knowledge of how to cook different traditional meals for husband, children and relatives could not preclude teachings in the fattening room. Findings revealed that Efik people have three-course meals and special delicacies. One of the caregivers explained that: Then they will tell you: for your husband to love you, these two things must be in place. One [is] his stomach so you must be knowledgeable in cooking all cuisines. Before you leave that seclusion, you are taught how to cook all kinds of dishes. You can cook this one today and you take it to your aunty or mother to taste first. She will teach you how to cook it. Then, the next day, she will drop all the ingredients and tell you [to] cook. If you make a mistake, she will correct you. [The] next day, it is another food, [and the] next day another food, until you are taught all the cuisines. And then the most difficult is ‘anyan ekpang’ (a morsel-type of a meal prepared with cocoyam and eaten with Banga soup) and ‘efere abak’ (Banga soup). They will tell you to cook it and sit down [to watch] you. In those days, our mothers could start from morning to prepare ‘abak’ (Banga soup) and ‘anyan ekpang’ till 4pm. So they [would] teach you all kinds of cuisines. After that they [would] teach you how to serve it. They [would] teach you the first-course meal. The Efik people have a three-course meal... The Efiks have what we call starters that is ‘ekpuba’ (specially prepared pork) and ‘edita iwa’ (slithered cassava, or tapioka) or unam mbakara (pork meat). They [would] tell you [to not keep waiting] your husband [when] you are about to prepare food. Put something in his face so that he can be busy, you know. And then, if it is not edita iwa, it can be ‘nnya’, that is garden egg and groundnut; or ‘ntokon ibong’, that is a special kind of Introduction 31 pepper source used in eating kola nut and garden egg. They [would] show you how to prepare it. You don’t give it to him while he has started eating, no! You give it to him while you are cooking and if there is a good fish – we call that kind of fish ‘ayara iyak’; that is fish that, during drying it, you remove the fatty part of it and keep the real fish part – then you put pepper on it and give him to eat. After that, when the food that you are preparing is ready, you serve him. Immediately after he finishes eating, you have to give him fresh palm wine to drink and that fresh palm wine does not go alone but with a little fish. Therefore, you may never know [in case] his friends are around. So, you don’t always give him one cup. Bring cups [just] in case anybody is walking past and sees ete drinking palm wine and wants to join him (Caregiver 1). From the above, serving the food is a major component of the culinary knowledge expected from nkuho training. Sexuality In the fattening room, the teachings about sexuality are all about how to make one’s husband happy sexually. In the Efik tradition, hygiene is key to sexuality. So, the maidens are taught to be neat all through, even during their menstrual cycle. Then, no woman should deny her husband sex. On this aspect, a maiden revealed as follows: About sex ... there is a white cloth that they will give you. They call it ‘ufung Idak abed’ or ‘ufung idak mmkpana’, which means ‘under pillow cloth’. They will give you and [say], when you meet your man, how to use it and clean yourself and they will teach you how to wash it, how to keep it clean and even when you are Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 32 menstruating. They will teach you your cycles. They will teach you how to use clothes. Like me, my grandmother taught me how to use [the] cloth when menstruating and that one was even better than this pad. After using it, you will wash it using hot water and sterilise it and fold it neatly again and fold it and cover it for next time. Yes, they teach you that you should not deny your husband sex, as many times as he needs you, you should not deny him (Maiden 2). Thus, being appealing to one’s husband with sweet words and how to be romantic and nice-looking have also been identified as complementary to being sexually attractive. In the description of one parent: And when you have finished taking your bath, dress very well. Carry your fine nightgown and wear it so that, when your husband turns to look at you, he will be attracted to you (Parent 1) ...A girl-child who is from Efik – I am not saying Akwa Ibom; I am not saying Ibibio, but Efik – can open her thighs without an odour coming out from her. The reason is that, from that first seclusion, you are taught how to insert your hand into your vagina so when you later have a girl-child and the girl child has a swap inside her vagina which God has put it there and the smell there is like onion and [whatever] comes out is whitish; it is not cream; it is not green; it is not red. So, by the time you fail to have this colour, it means you are sick. You put your hand every day in your body when you take your bath and bring out the swap and check. They will teach you that, whenever that swap changes from white to another colour, [you should] tell your mama. Maybe you have been infected from the toilet. They teach them to put their hand in their Introduction 33 body. Even till tomorrow, an Efik woman will put her hand in her body to clean it. They will also teach you that you are not supposed to leave hair in your armpit. They tell you that it will bring odour – unwanted odour – and then your private part; you bring it down and wash it very well not just to take your bath wuruwa! wuruwa! – that is, in a rush – and go away. You will take time to wash your private part very well; take time to care for that part. … And they will teach you that the moment you have sex with your husband – there is a cloth during the marriage ceremony that will be given to you, a towel, you will take it and wipe yourself. That cloth is always underneath the pillow and they will teach you that, when you finish having fun with your husband, use that towel and dab yourself and immediately you finish and your husband has gone out remove it and go and wash it, dry it, fold it and put it back there (Caregiver 3). For the Efik, there is no denying the significance of sexual education in the rites of coming-of-age. This preparation is deemed to serve a functional purpose in the overall cognitive process of the girl-child or bride-to-be in the world of the Efik, indeed as far as matrimonial responsibilities and expectations are concerned. Health Another teaching in the fattening room is on health. Findings revealed that there are usually talks on a healthy lifestyle. This is basically through good hygiene and the use of traditional medicines, like the white chalk, to beautify and treat rashes on the body. These are parts of health knowledge as evident in the excerpts below: In the fattening room, I was taught not to keep my armpit and pubic hairs. I was taught how to bathe in the morning Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 34 and evening, how to brush my teeth and I do them to keep myself hygienic (Maiden 4). I had vegetable soup, which they say is good for the body... In fact, I just ate most of the dishes, I won't lie. I can't remember what I was told, but that otor (grated water yam) helps in blood circulation especially as it's spiced with scent leaves, uyayak, and other spices. That mostly, when we put to bed, we would be made to take plenty of it and other slightly peppery foods with spices to help flush the system and boost the breast milk flow. But then, I also ate it even though I was not breastfeeding. They showed me how to make it and enjoy it (Maiden 3). This is to the extent to which folk education on health goes in the equipping of the maiden in the fattening room. Though the preparation around personal health may be perceived or appreciated from an individual-centred rite, it is, in a futuristic sense, an aspect of education that will become hands-on in the bride’s future matrimonial home, and, by extension, as a potential future caregiver in the fattening home and the Efik society at large. Skills Acquisition Based on the findings, there are various skill acquisition teachings in the fattening room. Maidens are taught language, craft carving, knitting, dancing, inscription-making, trading and cooking skills. This is evident in a Key Informant’s description below: Another aspect is the craft aspect. They teach you how to weave. We have our local ndam (wool). They will teach you the process of knitting ndam; from ndam wool to other things so that, at the end of the day, you don’t just believe in buying here, buying there. You are able to Introduction 35 do your thing and save money. On languages, they will teach you the regular emesiere (good morning greeting), ete omoyong (welcome sir), mma omoyong (welcome madam), idem fo? (how are you?) Amadia mkpo? (have you eaten?) Mmagha iso fo odo… (I don’t like the way you are keeping your face). She will try to straighten up her face because she has heard mmagha iso fo odo. Ndito idem mbufo..o (Children how are you doing?) Ah! Grandma idem mi usung or Idem mi isong ke (Grandma I am feeling well or I am not feeling fine). They will teach them that. Because most children never knew those things and their meaning, it is there at the fattening room that they were taught [this language skill] (KII, R5). [The making of] special, very special tray covers [is also taught] and I know that in some other places women were also taught how to carve the chewing stick. You know the Efiks have a special way of carving chewing sticks and these were all thought in the fattening room (FGDW, R3). So, one major advantage of the fattening room is the [teaching of] technical knowledge. All of these bring about creativity [for the maiden and intending wife]. Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 36 Plate 2: The research team and cooperative partners displaying sample design of textile weaving from nkuho skills acquisition training Introduction 37 Morality The last set of teaching as categorised in this report is morality. One maiden and another member of the female focus group discussant confirm to the research team what happens in this process: I love the fattening room because it broadens the child’s intellect. There are certain things you can never learn outside but you will learn them there. I learned personal hygiene, social training, self-discipline, cooking, emotional control, anger management, communication with your mate, communication with adults and elders, and home management skills. It was just an institution where you learn all that you need to know as a woman (Maiden 5). How you can endure pain, how you can listen more and talk less, how you can be observant of all the things around you and learn the lessons, and how you can take care of yourself emotionally (FGDW, R4). Consequently, in this process, the spirit and character of endurance, respect, self-esteem, emotional stability, mental alertness, and so on, are instilled in them. Objective 4 This section aims to produce a narrative of the fattening room practice of the Efik in Nigeria, against the backdrop of extrapolating a theory on gender, gender role, and identity in Africa. The fattening room exercise was one of the ways the Efiks preserved ancient beliefs, values, and customs. It was a cultural rite of passage that nurtured the young Efik female from girlhood to womanhood in a secluded room. The cultural characteristic of an ideal Efik female is signified in a young Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 38 virgin who had been pampered, ‘schooled’ with social and psychological resources, and forcefully fed with large portions of food to attain massive body size, curvaceous hips, and fleshy waistlines. Focus group discussions with men and women, and narratives of maidens, parents, caregivers, and key informants produce narratives which further establish this context: In my community, men usually go around scouting for maidens who are going through [the] nkuho institution (FGDM, R3). The nkuho in Efik tradition, as far as I know, goes by two aspects of life. Number one: When a girl-child is born and grows to the age of between 5 and 10, she is circumcised. That's the first nkuho. Number two: When the girl-child is of age or maybe, there is a suitor interested in her, the parents can decide to put her in a fattening room. From the fattening room, she is sent out after a specified time to her husband. It is a very beautiful cultural perspective in Efik land (FGDM, R5). You will be in a particular room after the circumcision… [in] the first one week, you will experience pain. When I was in the fattening room, I didn't do much. In the morning, I would eat, I would sleep, I would wake up and eat again. They would be petting me…When I woke up in the morning, I would take my bath. They would now massage my body with native chalk – that white chalk – before I even bathe. They would be using that on me…. After that, I would take my bath and they would use that same white chalk to rub my body. There is one yellow [thing] that they also use. I have forgotten its name. They would use it, mixed with that white chalk – I didn’t use cream – and camwood to design my body. In Introduction 39 fact, when you eat in the morning, it is for you to lie down and sleep…They will cook ‘otoh’, ekpang nkukwo. That first stage early in the morning I don’t always like because, early in the morning, they will give you garri. This garri they will soak overnight. Then, the following day, the garri will be so soft. They will put water in, and you drink it like water so that it will make you fat. You will be so fat. The food used to be plenty… They [would] put food in a big bowl. If it is rice, they will put it in a tray. If it is garri, there is a particular plate for that – a big plate. You must finish it. But, for me, I used to put a plate under my bed, when nobody [was around], I would turn it into that plate and hide because, if you didn’t finish it, they would talk to you in a way [that] you would not like. There used to be a time [when] they would teach me something… [When it is] the end, you know when they throw the water, so you enter. That day, there were some people, about 5 or 6 or 7 or 8.... And when they throw the water you run and enter and, in short, that day, it was merriment and they drank this ogogoro (ethanol dry gin) and when I was inside, I was hearing a kind of celebration. [There were] not many people, but the few people that were there…they will just buy this ogogoro and drink it. They use a cup and throw it on the roof and when the water [comes rushing] down and touches you, then you run into the house … That evening – you know in the neighbourhood there are other nkuho – then, I used to pass through the backyard to the other side to meet my colleagues. Sometimes they knew, maybe three of us would be in the house. We would talk, we would laugh, we played, and then they would go or, me too, I would return back. So, the night that I would come out, they would throw that water again and I would go out before coming into the room again...because now, I am free Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 40 after coming out. So I can go anywhere now. On Sunday, I went to church. They bought me new clothes. They called people, they cooked. That Monday was the market day, so as I dressed to the church on Sunday, the same way I dressed to the market on Monday (Maiden, 2). …Every morning, they would soak plenty of garri (fried cassava flakes) in water and leave it for hours to rise and be very soft such that you can drink it like a smooth paste. They bathe you and massage you with local white chalks (ndom). Sometimes, they mix ashes with the ndom to massage you. You are then given the soaked garri to drink so that you get fat. If you don’t get fat, they continue to keep you in the fattening room until they make sure you get fat. That is why some people are kept in the room for a very long time. After drinking the garri, they allow you to sleep. When you wake up, in the afternoon, they give you food again. In the evening, they give you other food… They teach you folk songs and traditional dances... You don’t go out... You don’t wear clothes, just the local chalk on your body. You can wear a small top if you have developed breasts. They roll your hair in knots called ikpok ube. They also decorate your face. Usually, you lay on a mat for you to sleep on. They normally don’t want the blood and oil to stain the bed sheet so you have to sleep on a mat… You are given a special seat… a round seat that is meant for you alone while in the fattening room…They also cover your legs with a cloth, since most of it is bare after the shorts. You are taken out as a maiden and dressed in special beads known as okpono on shorts. Your breasts are left bare while your wrist is adorned with beads. The seat in the tent is made for your coming-out celebration. The tent is called mkpoto, which looks more like what you now Introduction 41 see in traditional weddings. You dance the dance steps you were taught in the fattening room and people will dance around you. Although some maidens go to the market with someone who covers them [with an] umbrella as they shop for food- stuff, I never went to the market. But I was taken to church. It was for thanksgiving and I was dressed normally (Maiden, 4). They kept me in the house and fed me very well – you know they want to feed you so that you can get fat. Somebody would come every morning to massage me with ndom (native chalk) and [do] my hair. My sisters were big so they taught them how to take care of a home. People would come and sing and play with us in the evenings, teaching us how to sing and dance and so on. If you want to go out, you tell the others, ‘onungo mi, inungo fi’ (if you pip on me, I pip on you). Every morning, this woman would come and open our legs and check to be sure everything was okay. After about a month or so, we were dressed and escorted to the market where people gave us gifts. When we were back [at] the house, we had a 'Coming of Age' dance in the evening. After that, we went to church on Sunday to thank God (P2). [Most of the time], people misinterpret the practice of nkuho (fattening room). They think it's just to go there and get all fat. Yes, I'm fat but I know that it is not all about that... Just like the Western education teaches us the Western culture or the Western behaviour in schools, in universities, colleges, the fattening room is an institution. So, my parents noticed that many young girls grow up in certain families where they are pampered and some parents don't find time to teach them those Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 42 etiquettes of life. So, my parents wanted to instil more of the cultural practice in their female children. So, we just went in for the experience or the knowledge. It is now very typical of some Calabar girls that they don't know how to prepare the Efik-specific dishes; we have a lot of them – interesting and delicious ones. But there are few Calabar girls that can prepare those meals. And, with the way the Western world is taking over, a lot of our cultural food or practices is fading out of existence... So, my father wanted us to go there and have this culture- specific knowledge on what goes around in our environment... It was when I was 7 years old… as a matter of fact we just went in there to get knowledge. There are three types of nkuho. The infant nkuho. The adolescent nkuho (where young women are groomed by confinement during which they are taught the rudiments of marriage) and the childbirth nkuho (allows one to learn about parenthood and all the necessary knowledge on how to raise her child, care and give attention to that child) (Maiden 5). … as I grew older, I discovered that what was done to my sister on the eighth day was done to some girls in some homes when they're 5, 6, 7 years of age, when they're about to start schooling. At this time, they are kept in the fattening room and fed very well. They are beautifully dressed on the day they are brought out and taken to the market. The women will clap and cheer her with ululation (making the sound as in a demonstration) Esin okut e nonye (Give money to her) E tor enye ndom (Rub her with Ndom) Mbok, nonye udia o (Please give her food o) E nonye mmong o (Give her water o). People will appreciate her with those things – money, ndom, food items, water, etc. as she is taken round the market. Introduction 43 Why the market? I don't know. She's taken back to the house and taken to church the subsequent Sunday. The Reverend will bless her and she'll go and start schooling. That's stage one. The next stage is a training school. Like Ete had rightly said, at this time, there's a suitor waiting by. She's isolated and taught how to keep her home, relate with her in-laws, how to take care of her husband in all ramifications – sex, food, petting and other things. In that same fattening room, she will be taught how to make mbufari (a tablecloth – it must be included in the items that must accompany bride price), how to cook menus like ekpang-kukwo, obobot ikon, afang, edikang ikong... You know, when an Efik girl takes care of a man – maybe a visitor – he'll fall in love with her and you will hear people saying, Ohh, ononye ibok ima! (Ohh, she gave him a love potion). There's nothing like ibok ima. It is that art of caring and caregiving that ‘charmed’ the man into loving her. She's not yet a mother, but she's taught the art of becoming a mother which is expected to be soon. When the phase of traditional marriage proper comes and goes, she is sent into a 9-month course. In some homes, she will still be taken back into Ufok nkuho (fattening room) where more massaging on her will be done. She's fed with plenty of garri soaked and left for at least twenty-four hours to rise and soften. In three months’ time, when she's going for christening, she looks plumpy, sweet, fresh, sexy. The teaching of the art of a mother continues through all those phases – how to breastfeed a child and a lot of other things, [in a step by step fashion]. They come out properly trained to do things orderly and correctly, not like it is with our girls of today who do things anyhow. She's brought out at the expiration of three months, celebrated and taken to church (FGDM, R2). Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 44 …You know, nkuho was divided into three parts. The first part was the circumcision; the second part was the fattening of the woman to make her look plump and healthy. Instructors will come in daily to train her in different areas and fields of endeavour. Finally, In the end, the masquerade is brought in as a symbol of authority and government. Right now, we have the understanding that Ekpe masquerade also has some marine connotations. That is why, in some families, rituals involve them going to Efe Ekpe (Ekpe Hall) to do libation pouring and invoke some marine powers into those women before they proceed to their husbands’ house in marriage. However, this last phase does not apply to nkuho generally. It is not carried out in some families. So, the fattening room has the positive side and the negative side depending on the family. But, on the whole, it was a very good school designed for training women on all that was necessary – how to do well in life (FGDM, R1). We have three categories of nkuho…the first is that you are a child…between the ages of 7 and 12 years…The second stage is [between] the age of 15 to 18 years… You don’t know a man yet because, if you know a man and they take you and cut your clitoris, you will bleed to death. So, during that period, your grandma will be monitoring you, and the good thing there is, that each time you come back from school or stream, they will use an egg and measure your vagina if it has been tampered with. They will make sure that they monitor you seriously until the third term. You know you have first term and second term in school. They will leave it till the third term when you will stay at home for a month and Introduction 45 some weeks. So that is when they do it. It will not affect your schooling (Caregiver, 1). It is indeed against this backdrop that it has been documented – and as also highlighted earlier by this key informant – that: … there is this nkuho uto owo ndung ufot (nkuho that gives gifts to the lady). It is not the same thing as nkuho preparing you for marriage. Preparing you for marriage is different from making you come of age. At nkuho preparing you for ndo (marriage) you will be taught all these things we have mentioned. But for making you an akwa nwan (full woman). It is expected of us that, as we are sending out our daughter, we are not just selling her, so that no husband tomorrow will ask you: ‘When you came, what did you come with? [Of] everything in this house, show me what you came with. Not from our tribe. From our tribe here, [in] sending you off, we are sending you off fully. They will give you a full parlour setting. They will give you a kitchen setting. They will give you a full room setting as you are going to your husband's house and they will give you good money – good money (KII 5). … this particular seclusion is in her father’s compound…. She will come out in her maiden's outfit in which she is adorned. And she comes out and exhibits her talent… that is on Saturday or Friday. But it is usually done on Saturday so that she can be sent to the market. She has to go to the market where every other nkuho [mates] from different places [and communities] that have put their children in seclusion also [at] the same time like her – all the nkuho wherever they are – will come together in the market on Saturday. And it is on Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 46 Sunday that the father, the parent of the nkuho will invite everybody to come. They will give her an umbrella, [have her] wear her socks and gloves, and a small hat and a crown to walk to church – that is, nkuho goes to church. First, nkuho goes to market. Second, nkuho goes to church to thank God. After that is a big ceremony in their compound… where she will come out and dance and dance and dance. Again that is the first. But the second is not like that. [With the second], it is believed that she is put in seclusion to be given out in marriage. It means the first and second letter is given already and they [were] taught [how] they responded, where the father [was to] respond when the girl is put in seclusion (Caregiver, 1). … it is a rite of passage for a girl-child, you must start at the early age of 10..., between 10 and 18. By 10, we call it, 'nkuho eyen owon'. That is, as a girl-child, they will put you in a fattening room, separate, to prepare you to become a teen and going into adulthood…And it is expected to be that, when you are there at that time – maybe two, three... assuming you are 10 – you stay there for 3 years. That is, you're 13, you are a teen… You wake up, [and] your caregiver will now come in and be giving you training on how to become a full-grown woman – the food you will be cooking, how to do your laundry, how to dress your house, the cleaning aspects, the sanitary aspects of your own body and the family that you are going in [to], your house, your environment and your dance steps when it is the day that you will be coming out to see people (Caregiver 2). …I was there. My grandma would take me and bathe me. She would take me to the backyard and she would Introduction 47 continue pressing the wound…She would massage me. She will use white clay…there is a special leaf – the Edada mmeme leaf which she used to massage me. Then you don’t go out. They will still put clay inside the water and rub you. Then you will sit on a mat on the floor. So they will bring you food and water. Early in the morning, they will give you garri that they soaked overnight to sip and you [are not allowed to] use a spoon. You will drink it in a big bowl [laughs] so that you will be fat now. We have a special seat that you will sit on, so nobody sits there…You will be well drilled and taught. And they will make sure that you internalise them…You must sleep, you must eat because it is assumed that, by the time you are to come out from the fattening room, you should be [voluptuous]… They will teach you how to dance different dance steps… They teach you ‘nke’ [She sang the song making the sound that was used with her mouth and hands]. They taught us how to tell stories; poems proverbs and all those kinds of things…When the moonlight comes out, [all you fellow maidens that were circumcised], will come out…When it is close to the coming-out ceremony, they will come around then you will come and sing and dance together and go to the market. When you go to the market, they will [gift money to us]… You just walk around, with an umbrella. You will be well dressed… Immediately they see you they will be hailing you “o.. nkuho edi udua..o” (Nkuho has come to the market..o)… After coming from the church, first before we move to the market… people will then dash you money …They will admire you and then, from the market, you will now go home and you come to sit on mkpoto…That is when the ceremony will begin and that will happen from around 5:30pm downwards… People will come out and dance…If you are from a royal Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 48 home, they will dress in our Efik traditional dress. They will dance. You too, you will dance, too. The mother of the girl will come and she will put this white chalk in water and rub it on the girls, saying ‘My daughter has passed through nkuho...o (mmo no eyen mi nkuho..o)…(Maiden, 1). … if we want to discuss nkuho, we have to follow it step by step…from the first day and the rites and the last day and the rites. So this for me rounds up the narrative for nkuho. You know [how] to prepare your daughter for womanhood in terms of what is expected of her as a grown-up. You start from a process. You know the first process is the seclusion rites …and the seclusion rites begin with circumcision…So, we have the seclusion house/room prepared, so you have to put her in a seclusion room – a room where nobody can have access to, usually in the backyard. In the configuration of her ancient cultural compound, there are some cultural things that need to be done…You then have to use palm fronds to picket the doors and the room that is going to be used for the circumcision rites… ensuring that it is fortified traditionally by all powers against every power that will want to come and put your daughter’s life in danger… If somebody comes there with an evil mind, he or she should not be able to cross that picket yard to enter the room. The evil must not be able to penetrate that house… Usually, there is a particular plant called ‘urun’ in my local language. It must be there at the entrance to that room… So, while this seclusion room is being prepared, also your ban, your storehouse – how many yam tubers have you gathered? How long will they last? Is it for one planting season? How long do you plan to put her in the room? What is/are physiological attributes? Introduction 49 Nkuho is about eating, feeding, forceful feeding … There is ukang ukum (cowtail plantain). There is edesi (rice). There is edita iwa (slice cassava or Tapioca)… to make her outgrow her age; to make her outgrow nature; to make her so grown to fulfil somebody’s fantasy; to see her beautiful – that is who we are. In my family, [by] 6 O’clock in the morning, you are fed with one bowl of water. By 6:10am, they bring a bowl of garri, soaked, and one long big fish. By 6:15am, you are given pounded yam and soup. The food cycle ticks round the clock – at most a ten-fifteen-minute interval. They had their own belief and so the girl-child who must undergo nkuho must go through this painful process (of circumcision)… The woman who is vested [with the task of] doing the circumcision would have been there. [she is seen as a] woman walking in with her small girl, holding her bag that contains the implements and her red flag and a round bell and a pot…The girl is pinned down by young men … She will chop off part of the girl’s genitalia and then she stops the blood using native leaves… Because of the traditional things being used, after three days, the circumcision would have dried up and blackened up with the herbs – African traditional herbs that have been used. If, after four or five days, the wound is still fresh, then there is a problem; something must have gone wrong. Within the house, another school begins...for humanity, for people that she will interact with, for the man she will marry, for the society and the people she will live with (KII, 1). Furthermore, participation in the fattening room exercise provided social integration, personal standards or prestige, statuses, social regulatory mechanisms, and identity, against Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 50 which the Efiks regulated their own behaviour and societal expectations: The parents that get their children through the nkuho process are respected for respecting and maintaining the family value. It was a common practice in the 60s to the 80s. But, it is no more popular today because of the changes and the technology of the new world (FGDM, R5). So, I am a man. I have children [and] I want to showcase my daughters, and I will tell you in the next season or so many seasons to come, it is either I am preparing my daughters for marriage to a king’s son, a prince or so. So, like a fatted cow or a Good Shepherd that wants to go for an agricultural show, you want to showcase your ‘fatted’ or your best cow, your best bull. You want to bring it out for people to see. It comes from deep within; it is a thing of pride to showcase. So, to get to that point where you probably showcase your valued asset to the public to see so that they can begin to price. So, in this case, the nkuho is being prepared so that others can come and see. For instance, back in the day, I [could] see a small child, who [would] go to the stream even at age ten and I [could] say, ‘Okay I am going to betroth this girl for my son. I believe my son will marry this one’, and I do some stuff, the needful. It, therefore, behoves me as a parent to bring up this child in such a way and manner that, every day, as I am passing by, you will be hastening the time laps for her growth, so that they can come and carry her… (KII, 1). I am an indigene of Calabar, Efik, to be precise. I am from Ikot Nkpam Nkpan. My parents are both Efiks. My Introduction 51 Dad is a traditionalist, a cultural man. He was interested in the culture of his people. I used to live outside with my parents when my father was alive – he is late. He was a civil servant working with the Nigerian Embassy before he got posted to various countries as his job permitted. We used to accompany him. Since we were seven girls, he wanted us to have a firsthand experience of our culture and inherit something from our culture which is the practice of nkuho (Maiden 5). A typical Efik man will be very proud of marrying a well-groomed woman… Yeah! …the ego of an Efik man. He wants to see [his] wife serve him very well. So he will really bring out the cash. So he uses the cash to take care of [himself]... He wants to be behind and the wife [who is] in front, [while he] raises his shoulder – this is my pride. (FGDW, 4). … It is a [thing of] pride…you go through the process and you come out feeling different. You come out feeling you've achieved something. You know, you are ready for something (KII, 4). [Singing] Mbre ye afo so, mma mma anwan etete...kpok mbara-ukot, kpok ubok..o, yak edifo etie do, ada enye odo anam asian..o, mbre ye afo so... This particular song connotes that, anybody who does not pass through the rites of passage has no right to enter where other girls are staying because they will abuse her saying, mma mma anwan etete (cut your fingernail, cut your toenails too, but leave your long clitoris to be there, so that you may use it to make love as a man). That will make you run away [as a girl who has not undergone female circumcision]. Anybody in the village [who] does not Re-Examining Gender, Gender Roles and Identity In Nigeria: The Fattening… 52 pass through the rites of passage – every maiden in the village will abuse her as they sing that [song], nobody in the village will tell them to go away. They will [by themselves] run away (Caregiver 1). …[Emphatically] Then, there used to be this belief that it was only a rich father that could afford to put their daughter in the fattening room, feed her and bring people to teach her. The food the caregivers cook is not only for the girl. [The caregivers] too will take [part of it] away. So, it was only a rich home that could afford that so I had that good feeling (Maiden 6). As a caregiver, you are recognised in the whole village and being talked about. That is part of [the] compensation (Caregiver 2). In addition, the fattening room exercise was an intentional attempt to promote chastity, curb pre-marital sex, and prevent promiscuity and extra-marital affairs among Efik females. Thus, female children were coaxed into having their clitorises removed. Female circumcision, therefore, was at the core of the exercise as detailed in the earlier narratives and those following from here: … when they bring you in during that time they will not tell you that today is your day. In short the day you start seeing them dash [out] food, big meat, big fish, roasted plantain [to you], they want to make your mind settle and be at peace. In fact, you can see your grandma go and bring you fine cloth and dash [it out to] you so as to settle your mind; because, if you know that tomorrow they will temper with [your] genitals, you will run away… you will escape. So, they will pet you, then, early in the Introduction 53 morning, before 5am, they will trick you to go and take your bath. ‘We want to go for morning prayers’ (‘Akam Usen ubok’ – early morning prayer) and your head will be [swollen] because they have [gifted] you this and that. And then, when you come out, because you will be happy to follow them, then they will take you out of your room. You must have dressed and worn your pants. Then, my grandma would ask, ‘What kind of pants are you wearing? What type of dress is this? Go and change it. Let me give you something that will take you to where we are going.’ When you go to remove your clothes and wear a new attire, from there, you will see a man and, before you go to that place, they will do the circumcision. They put fresh plantain leaves on the floor and then they put deadwood on top of it. And then you come and they say, ‘Lie down.’ And, before you say you want to run, you can’t run because this man standing there will grab you and you will be shouting ‘ekaeka mi o’ (O my grandmother!) Your grandmother will be telling you that it doesn’t [hurt] that she is the on