71 Harnessing Digital Tools for Primary Healthcare Delivery: A Case Study from Mascot Healthcare Clinic, Akoka, Lagos State, Nigeria Kehinde Lawal Abstract This paper presents a case study of the implementation of digital tools at Mascot Healthcare Clinic, a primary healthcare clinic in Nigeria. As a third world country with serious healthcare challenges, Nigeria needs the added benefit of digital medicine to enhance delivery of healthcare services. Mascot Healthcare integrates remote consultations, ultrasound and laboratory diagnostics using technology, providing solutions to health challenges in reproductive health, preventive medicine and routine outpatient services. This paper explores the successes, challenges, and future possibilities for digital medicine in low-resource environments, with a particular focus on lessons learned for replicability in similar settings. Keywords: Digital Medicine, Telemedicine, Primary Healthcare, Diagnostics, Low- resource Settings, Nigeria, Patient Engagement 1. Introduction The continuous technological advancement in the world has significantly improved access, effectiveness and safety of healthcare service. In developing nations like Nigeria, where healthcare access is limited due to infrastructure gaps, digital solutions offer a promising approach to bridging these gaps (Elendu et al, 2023). The improving access to internet has further accelerated the adoption of digital healthcare solutions in Nigeria, underscoring the importance of telemedicine, diagnostics, and digital engagement tools (Olumide Sunday, 2004). Mascot Healthcare Clinic, a startup clinic based in Akoka, Lagos, is leveraging on socially acceptible technology to improve healthcare delivery at primary care level. This case study seeks to provide an account of our ©Machine Intelligence Research Group, University of Lagos V. Odumuyiwa et. al. (Eds.): MIRG-ICAIR 2024, pp. 71–76, 2024. unique experience, challenges, and recommendations. 2. Background: The Nigerian Healthcare Context Nigeria, being the most populous black nation, faces serious healthcare challenges and has been continuosly burdened by high maternal motarlity, infant mortality, prevalence of malaria and chronic diseases. The healthcare picture usually worsened by ineffective government policies, poor funding, inadequate infrastructures and a severe shortage of healthcare workers (Fatunmole, 2022) In Nigeria, economic pressures such as high inflation and an unfavourable exchange rate have severely impacted healthcare delivery, particularly by contributing to a mass emigration of medical professionals seeking better pay and working conditions abroad. Between 2015 and 2021, nearly 5,000 Harnessing Digital Tools for Primary Healthcare Delivery: A Case Study from Mascot Healthcare Clinic, Akoka, Lagos State, Nigeria 72 Nigerian doctors relocated to the UK alone. A 2024 report noted that as many as 16,000 doctors have left in recent years, leaving Nigeria with a ratio of only two doctors per 10,000 people in many areas outside major cities. This shortage leads to overburdened hospitals and burnout among the remaining healthcare workers, which diminishes the quality of care available to patients. Compounding this issue, public sector general doctors in Nigeria earn about 350,000 Naira per month, which makes it challenging for them to sustain their own livelihoods amidst rising costs of essentials, including transportation and medical supplies (Vanguard, BusinessDay). The healthcare landscape in Nigeria is predominantly occupied by Primary healthcare, defined by the World Health Organization as a whole-of-society approach to health and well-being centered on the needs and preferences of individuals, families, and communities. It addresses the broader determinants of health and focuses on the comprehensive and interrelated aspects of physical, mental, and social health and well-being. It provides whole-person care for health needs throughout the lifespan, not just for a set of specific diseases. According to the WHO, primary healthcare encompasses three key components:  Integrated health services – that meet most people's health needs across prevention, wellness, treatment, and palliative care.  Community participation – empowering people to take charge of their own health.  Multisectoral policy and action – addressing social, economic, and environmental factors to improve health outcomes (WHO, 2002). In last decades, technological advancement has strenghtened the healthcare sector through advancement in diagnostic equipments, therapeutic science, research, communication and management softwares. Telemedicine, defined as the practice of using digital technology to provide healthcare services remotely, allowing patients to connect with healthcare providers via video calls, phone calls, or messaging softwares, enabling consultations, diagnoses, and even treatment without an in-person visit (WHO, 2010). Telemedicine has been growing in poularity in around the world and in Nigeria, typically offered as mobile applications which connects doctors and patients; other applications in Nigeria include electronic health records, health promotion and remote radiodiagnosis. Mascot Healthcare, a newly established and licensed primary healthcare provider in Lagos state, offers real insights from into how these digital tools can make healthcare delivery more efficient and accessible in a challenging environment. 3. Telemedicine: Bridging the Gap 3.1 Telemedicine Services at Mascot Healthcare Mascot Healthcare is structured to offer online and hybrid telemedicine services to improve access for patients. Utilizing basic video and chat platforms, the clinic provides virtual consultations for treatment of minor ailments, counselling and hybrid online clinic follow-ups. This has been achieved through the secure web-based telemedicine and health promotion app, Teleclinic web app for chronic diseases 73 follow up, implementation of electronic health records (EHR), patient portals and online health promotion. 3.2 Impact of Telemedicine The telemedicine platform has had a positive impact on healthcare delivery by providing access to counselling, medical diagnosis and treatment to Nigerians, reducing patient wait times and offering more flexible scheduling (Baldwin et al, 2003). This service also allows for continuity of care, follow up on investigation reports, medical certificate sharing and for monitoring chronic conditions such as hypertension and diabetes, where regular follow-ups are essential. Telemedicine has been particularly effective in chronic disease management, including diabetes and hypertension (Neufeld et al, 2012). The digital tools deployed by Mascot Healthcare to improve healthcare delivery and efficiency have demonstrated remarkable potentials. Within 6 months of inception, patients attended to has increased to 600 patients. With a patient base of 95% lagos-based and the remaining 5% spread across the country. This has eliminated running cost associated with paper-based record- keeping and crowd control, making the services more affordable for patients. Patient retention, follow up and continuity of care has also been consistent largely due to affordable care, little waiting time and effective technology-based diagnosis, follow up and treatment. 3.3 Challenges and Solutions While the benefits of telemedicine are clear, challenges remain. Being a relatively new and evolving modality of healthcare delivery, there has been some inertia in adoption of digital healthcare by patients and some partner providers. The price of electricity and internet is also high which hinders patient access to this digital care. The financial and labor cost of installing and maintaining this healthcare method can be overwhelming for small clinics and hospitals without financial assistance, as was the case with Mascot Healthcare too. To partly overcome these barriers, Mascot Healthcare is improving on patient education, offering guidance on using our digital tools and ensuring that consultations are accessible via mobile phones, which are more common than computers. Further financial assistance and support from the governement will ensure the growth and sustainability of telemedicine in Nigeria (Adedoyin et al, 2024). 4. Digital Patient Engagement and Health Promotion 4.1 Social Media and Digital Health Education To engage patients beyond direct care, Mascot Healthcare has adopted a proactive digital health promotion strategy. The clinic is active on social media platforms to conduct health education campaigns, sharing information about preventive measures, early warning signs of illnesses, and general wellness tips. Interactive content, such as quizzes on common medical conditions, has proven effective in improving patient health literacy and fostering engagement. Harnessing Digital Tools for Primary Healthcare Delivery: A Case Study from Mascot Healthcare Clinic, Akoka, Lagos State, Nigeria 74 4.2 Community Engagement Outcomes By adopting online health promotion, Mascot Healthcare has built stronger relationships with its patient base. Our social media platform serves as an additional channel for delivering health education and maintaining contact with patients, even between visits. This has been particularly helpful in encouraging preventive care, such as health maintenance visits, symptoms triage and reproductive health services. 5. Challenges in Implementing Digital Solutions in Low-resource Settings Implementing digital solutions in Nigeria presents several systemic challenges, which Mascot Healthcare has had to address. These include:  Infrastructure limitations: Power outages and internet instability often affect the seamless delivery of telemedicine and online patient follow-up  Cost and access: Many patients cannot afford the cost of smartphones or data plans necessary for engaging in digital consultations.  Cultural and behavioral barriers: Skepticism about non-physical healthcare interactions persists among some patients, making them hesitant to adopt telemedicine. Mascot Healthcare has responded by creating low-cost options for telemedicine consultations and offering hybrid models where patients can start with digital consultations and come in for in-person visits when necessary or vice-versa. The clinic also embarked on continuous awareness campaign and promotion about the effectiveness and comfort of Telemedicine. 6. Lessons Learned 6.1 Lessons from Telemedicine Adoption Since introducing telemedicine and expanded outpatient services in March 2024, Mascot Healthcare has attended to 600 patients. More than 90% of these cases were delivered either partially or fully through telemedicine, demonstrating the critical role of digital health tools in improving healthcare access and efficiency in low-resource settings which aligns with the general growth in telemedicine use in Nigeria during the COVID-19 pandemic (Adebayo et al., 2020). The most important lesson from Mascot Healthcare’s telemedicine adoption is the need for simplicity and accessibility. Patients are more likely to engage with digital tools if the platforms are easy to use, dependable and affordable. Patients benefit from the comfortable healthcare access, easy scheduling, short waiting time and online access to follow up thereby reducing cost of another clinic visit. These advantages were also demonstrated in studies done with multiple Telemedicine clinics in the United States (Varkey P. et al, 2008) Training staff to support patients in accessing telemedicine services has also been crucial to its success. This ensures continuos improvement, increased effective healthcare delivery and minimizes medical errors (Blocker A et al, 2024). 75 6.2 Engaging Communities via Social Media Effective community engagement through digital platforms has shown that simple, regular, accessible health education can drive better health outcomes. Offering information that is clear and actionable can help patients take charge of their own health. 7. Conclusion Mascot Healthcare’s case study demonstrates that digital medicine offers powerful tools for improving primary healthcare delivery in low- resource settings. Through telemedicine, diagnostics, and patient engagement, the clinic has been able to extend its healthcare reach and foster better patient relationships. While challenges remain, the potential for digital medicine to address key gaps in healthcare is enormous. As Mascot Healthcare continues to evolve, the lessons learned from its experiences will serve as valuable insights for similar clinics and healthcare providers across developing nations. List of References Olumide Sunday Adewale, An internet- based telemedicine system in Nigeria, International Journal of Information Management, Volume 24, Issue 3, 2004, Pages 221-234, Fatunmole, M. (2022). "Four doctors to 10,000 population, Nigeria's highest in two decades - Data." ICIR. Available at: ICIR Nigeria. Elendu, Chukwuka, et al. "The Role of Telemedicine in Improving Healthcare Outcome: A Review." Advances in Research, vol. 24, no. 5, 2023, pp. 55-59. https://doi.org/10.9734/air/202 3/v24i5958(JournalAir) Adedoyin, A, and Adebayo, O. "Telemedicine Revolution: Legal Implications and Regulatory Compliance for Healthcare Providers in Nigeria." Mondaq, 2024. https://www.mondaq.com/niger ia/healthcare/1464228 (Brieflands) Neufeld, J., Case, R., & Serricchio, M. (2012). Walk-in telemedicine clinics improve access and efficiency: A program evaluation from the perspective of a rural community mental health center. Journal of Rural Mental Health, 36(2), 33–37. https://doi.org/10.1037/h00958 13 Baldwin L, Clarke M, Hands L, Knott M, Jones R. The effect of telemedicine on consultation time. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare. 2003;9(1_suppl):71-73. doi:10.1258/135763303322196 420 Varkey P, Schumacher K, Swanton C, Timm B, Hagen PT. Telemedicine in the work site: a study of feasibility, and patient and provider satisfaction. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare. 2008;14(6):322-325. doi:10.1258/jtt.2008.080512 Blocker A, Datay MI, Mwangama J, Malila B. Development of a telemedicine virtual clinic system for remote, rural, and underserved areas using user- centered design methods. DIGITAL HEALTH. 2024;10. Harnessing Digital Tools for Primary Healthcare Delivery: A Case Study from Mascot Healthcare Clinic, Akoka, Lagos State, Nigeria 76 doi:10.1177/205520762412567 52 World Health Organization. (2020). Primary health care. World Health Organization. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/news- room/fact- sheets/detail/primary-health- care. World Health Organization. (2010). Telemedicine: Opportunities and developments in Member States. Report on the Second Global Survey on eHealth. Geneva: World Health Organization. Retrieved from https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/ 10665/44497.